ORDER ONLINE FOR DELIVERY + PICKUP

Savor the Flavors of Fatman’s Pizza!

A Slice of Buffalo’s Finest



Fatman’s Pizza is more than just a pizza shop; we’re a hub of community flavor. From our original Buffalo, NY-based pizza and wings to our monthly specials, every slice tells a story of quality and authenticity. Join us as we redefine the pizza experience, blending tradition, the freshest ingredients, and our passion to bring you the best flavors this city has to offer.

Wings at Fatman's Pizza
Pizza at Fatman's Pizza

Our Menus

Catering

Explore Our Delicious Menu Creations



Sweet Pizza & Savory Wings

Jam Packed Calzones

Refreshing Salads

Hot & Cold Subs Made to Order

Tasty Appetizers

Calzones at Fatman's Pizza
Specialty pizza at Fatman's Pizza

Bring Fatman’s To Your Function



Looking to add a dash of Buffalo’s finest flavors to your next gathering? We’ve got you covered with our catering menu! Whether it’s a touchdown-worthy football party, a birthday bash, or a work gathering, let us bring the irresistible taste of Buffalo to your event. Indulge in our catering menu filled with delicious options, crafted with local ingredients.

See What Others Are Saying About Fatman’s Pizza!



Ready to discover the best of Buffalo’s pizza scene?
Order online now or call 716-693-7477!

January 2026 Specials

Personal Stuffed Crust Pizza 11.99
A 4-slice personal pizza, with your choice of one topping, filled with a cheese stuffed crust.

Spicy Chorizo Potato Bites 12.99
Homemade chorizo, habanero peppers, smashed potatoes and shredded smoked gouda, rolled in breadcrumbs and deep fried to perfection. Served with green chili sauce on the side.

Cheese Stuffed Hungarian Peppers 13.99
Three peppers stuffed with cheddar, smoked gouda, pepperjack and romano cheese, topped with mozzarella and baked to perfection.

Rodeo Chicken Finger Mac-n-Cheese 14.99
A diced BBQ chicken finger and french’s fried onions over our homemade mac-n-cheese.