Our Story

With a long, storied history in the Amherst and Tonawanda area, Fatman's Pizza has begun the next chapter of its journey under new ownership beginning in November 2018. Offering fresh and authentic Buffalo-style pizza, topped with all of your favorites including cup-n-char pepperoni, crumbled sausage or fresh vegetables, Fatman's Pizza looks to deliver on it's daily promise to keep you coming back for more.

Now owned by Jeff Galdys, the goal has never changed: to make sure the customer has one memorable experience after another. Jeff began his career at The Fatman Pizzeria back in 2005 and has worked in different Western New York restaurants for over 14 years. With experience in multiple kitchen environments, he is able to bring new approaches and details to this local area staple. But Jeff has also made it very clear he knows the most important part of this business, and that's you, the customer.

After adding some new items, Fatman's Pizza looks to have something for every customer; so, drop in for a slice, and don't forget to say hello!