Fatman’s Pizza Menus
Satisfy Your Cravings
For comfort food enthusiasts in Buffalo, NY seeking a culinary adventure beyond the traditional, look no further than Fatman’s Pizza. We’re more than just a pizza restaurant – we’re a destination for food lovers who want to experience the best of Buffalo’s culinary scene. Our menu is filled with delicious, handcrafted dishes that are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients. From our famous pizza to our mouthwatering wings, calzones, subs, and more, there’s something for everyone at Fatman’s Pizza!
Order for pickup or delivery!
Call 716-693-7477
Order Online
Our menu is a testament to Buffalo’s vibrant food scene, offering a unique blend of flavors and local ingredients that set us apart. From savory appetizers to hearty entrees and indulgent desserts, each item is crafted with passion and care to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Explore our specials and discover what makes us a favorite among food lovers in Buffalo!
Everyday Combos & Specials
Monthly Specials
Pizza of the Month
Calzone of the Month
Monthly Specialty Pizza List
Pizza
Wings & Fingers
Calzones
Subs
Salads
Apps & Sides
Dessert
Our pizzas are crafted using our signature semi-sweet sauce or garlic marinara sauce. The default option is semi-sweet unless otherwise specified.
Enhance any pizza by adding a delectable garlic crust or honey butter crust!
Toppings
Extra Cheese, Cup-n-Char Pepperoni, italian Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Meatballs, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Cherry Peppers, Fresh Green Peppers, Fresh Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Tomatoes, Garlic, Pineapple
Pizza Pricing
Personal: $8.99
Small: $14.99
Large: $20.99
1/2 Tray: $27.49
Tray: $38.99
Additional Toppings
Personal: $1.00
Small: $1.50
Large: $3.00
1/2 Tray: $4.00
Tray: $5.50
Pizza of the Month
Small $23.99 | Large $34.99 | 1/2 Tray $39.99 | Tray $49.99
January
Calamari Fra Diavolo
February
March
April
May
June
Fat Mac
July
Hot Honey, Ricotta and Basil
August
Spicy Mediterranean Sausage
September
Pittsburgh Steak
October
Chicken and Waffles
November
December
Chicken Parm de Vodka
Calzone of The Month
$14.99
January
Maple Bacon Rodeo Burger
February
March
Five Cheese
April
May
Tequila Lime Grilled Chicken
June
July
Fried Green Tomato
Fried Green Tomatoes, Bacon Crumbles, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Ricotta. Served With a Side of Poblano Avocado Ranch.
August
Chicken Bacon Ranch
September
Spicy Fried Pickle
October
November
Stinger Supreme
December
French Onion
Specialty Pizzas
White Tomato and Onion
Price:
Small $20.99
Large $29.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99
Choose up to (4) toppings, over a white garlic crust. Standard will come with tomato and onion.
Hawaiian Supreme (NEW)
Price:
Small $21.49
Large $30.99
1/2 Tray $37.99
Tray $45.99
Chopped ham, bacon crumbles, red onion, pickled jalapeno, pineapple chunks, cheddar, mozzarella and provolone cheeses over our semi-sweet sauce. Finished with a honey BBQ drizzle.
Poor Man’s Lasagna
Price:
Small $21.49
Large $30.99
1/2 Tray $37.99
Tray $45.99
Chopped meatballs, ricotta dollops, mozzarella cheese and italian spices over our garlic marinara sauce.
Chicken Finger Pizza
Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $40.49
Tray $49.99
Diced chicken fingers, with your choice of sauce, and topped with mozzarella cheese over a bleu cheese base.
Stuffed Pepper (NEW)
Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $40.49
Tray $49.99
Your choice of our AWARD-WINNING sausage stuffed hungarian peppers, buffalo chicken stuffed peppers, or nashville chicken stuffed peppers, and mozzarella cheese over a garlic butter base. *nashville chicken includes dill pickle chips and hot honey finish*
Meat Lovers
Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $40.49
Tray $49.99
Pepperoni, italian sausage, ham and bacon, with mozzarella cheese over your choice of sauce.
Fat Mac (NEW)
Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $40.49
Tray $49.99
Chopped smash burgers, dill pickle chips, onion, yellow american and mozzarella cheese over our homemade fat mac sauce.
Philly (Steak or Chicken)
Price:
Small $25.99
Large $37.49
1/2 Tray $44.99
Tray $54.99
Choice of chopped rib-eye steak or grilled chicken, sautéed with green peppers, mushrooms and onions, with yellow american, romano and mozzarella cheeses over a white garlic base.
Split Pizza
Price:
Large +$3.00
1/2 Tray +$3.50
Tray +$5.00
Get two different pizzas in one! The higher-priced pizza choice will determine the price. The Works Pizza is not available for split.
Served with blue cheese, carrots, and celery. Wings cannot be returned for being too hot! Try our wings and fingers on the chargrill!
$1.50 upcharge ($3.00 for a bucket of wings)
Extra Bleu Cheese $1.50
Extra Veggies $1.50
Calzones
Served with sides of pizza sauce unless specified otherwise.
Subs
Cold Subs & Hot Subs
All rolls are toasted. Subs come with a choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Subs come with a choice of mayonnaise or oil. Subs come with a choice of Swiss-American cheese, provolone, or yellow-American cheese. (Unless specified otherwise)
Salads
Dressings will be served on the side, served with garlic toast.
Dressings:
Bleu Cheese, Ranch, Italian, Greek, Caesar, French and our homemade bleu cheese
Add Ons:
Add Chicken: $3.00/$6.00
Extra Meat: $3.00
Extra Dressing: $1.00
Apps & Sides
Everyday Combos & Specials
Seafood Friday
Only Available on Friday
Beer Battered Fish Fry
An 8-10 oz homemade beer-battered cod fish fry. Served with fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, tartar sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.
$16.99
Shrimp Basket
10 jumbo deep-fried tail-on shrimp served with our fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, cocktail sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.
$14.99
Dessert
Apple Pie Logs
Served with caramel sauce.
$8.99
Cinnamon Sticks
Topped with vanilla icing.
$6.99
Monthly Specials
Specials October 2026
Breakfast Logs 10.99
From the maker of “Pizza Logs”, filled with scrambled egg and bacon crumbles. Served with maple syrup on the side.
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla 11.99
Chopped chicken fingers, tossed in medium sauce, in a crispy homemade quesadilla with cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, and a buffalo style pico. Served with our homemade bleu cheese dressing on the side.
Three Cheese Steak Stromboli 14.99
Chopped ribeye, cheddar, provolone and mozzarella cheeses in a homemade stromboli. Served with garlic aioli on the side.
Oahu Schnitzel Melt 14.99
Marinated pork schnitzel, grilled ham, swiss cheese, pineapple salsa, mayo and hot honey between a pressed rustic roll. Served with fresh cut french fries and a pickle.
Feeling hungry yet? Call 716-693-7477 or order online today!