Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
Fatman's Pizza
  • Menus
    Menu Weekly Specials Pizza of the Month
  • Catering
  • About
  • Contact
  • (716) 693-7477
tray cheese pepperonicalzone

Menu

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Menu

Appetizers & Sides

Fresh-Cut French Fries

$3.99
Fresh-Cut French Fries
2 reviews
2 reviews
 

Onion Rings

$4.99
Onion Rings
1 review
1 review
 

Pizza Logs

$5.99

(5)

11 pop
 

Homemade Mac-N-Cheese

$7.99
Homemade Mac-N-Cheese
1 review
11 pop1 review
 

Stuffed Hungarian Peppers

$11.99

(3) Topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Stuffed Hungarian Peppers
1 review
1 review
 

Deli Style Potato Chips

$3.99

Original or Cajun

 

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.99

(5)

 

Taco Logs

$5.99

(5) served with sour cream

Taco Logs
 

Bread Sticks

$9.99

Served with dipping sauce.

Bread Sticks
1 review
1 review
 

Salads

Dressings Will Be Served on The Side, Served with Garlic Toast
Dressings:
Golden Italian, Ranch, Sweet Italian, Greek, Caesar, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Lite Italian, French, Oil and Vinegar
Add Chicken $1.75 / $3.50 
Extra Meat: $3.00 | Extra Dressing: $1.00

Chef Salad**

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese.

Small $5.99Large $8.99
 

Antipasto Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese.

Small $7.99Large $10.99
Antipasto Salad
 

Caesar Salad**

A bed of romaine lettuce topped with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.

Small $5.99Large $8.99
Caesar Salad**
 

Greek Salad**

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black and green olives, feta cheese, and pepperoncini; served with pita.

Small $6.99Large $9.99
Greek Salad**
 

Julienne Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, turkey, and mozzarella cheese.

Small $7.99Large $10.99
 

Buffalo Chicken Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese with your choice of fingers.

Small $7.99Large $10.99
 

Subs

All rolls are toasted. Subs come with choice of lettuce, tomatoes, onions. Subs come with choice of mayonnaise or oil. Subs come with choice of swiss-american cheese, provolone, or yellow-american cheese. (unless specified otherwise)
Extra Toppings: $0.50 Extra Meat: $1.50
Add Bacon $1.00 / $2.00

Ham Sub

served cold

8" $7.4912" $9.99
Ham Sub
1 review
1 review
 

Assorted Sub

served cold

8" $7.4912" $9.99
 

Grilled Chicken Sub

marinated in Mum's sauce

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Sausage Sub

made with Italian Sausage patties

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Turkey Sub

served cold

8" $7.4912" $9.99
Turkey Sub
1 review
1 review
 

BLT Sub

with cheese

8" $7.4912" $9.99
 

Steak Sub

8" $8.4912" $10.99
Steak Sub
2 reviews
2 reviews
 

Cheeseburger Sub

made with fresh 4 oz. burger patties

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Speciality Subs

Philly Sub

(Steak, Chicken, or Sausage) with sautéed green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and melted yellow-American cheese.

8" $9.9912" $12.99
Philly Sub
3 reviews
3 reviews
 

Stinger Sub

(Steak and Chicken Fingers) with melted provolone cheese
Your choice of fingers
Your choice of mayo, oil, bleu cheese or ranch

8" $9.9912" $12.99
Stinger Sub
 

Meatball Parm Sub

made with your choice of sauce

8" $8.4912" $10.99
Meatball Parm Sub
 

Sausage Parm Sub

made with your choice of sauce

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Fatman's Meatball

with your choice of banana peppers, green peppers or onions, order it loaded with all three! made with your choice of sauce

8" $9.9912" $12.99
 

Chicken Finger Sub

Your choice of fingers
Your choice of mayo, oil, bleu cheese or ranch
Your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion

8" $8.4912" $10.99
Chicken Finger Sub
1 review
1 review
 

Royal Sub

(Steak, Chicken, or Sausage) with Capicola.

Your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion
Your choice of mayo, oil or both

8" $8.4912" $10.99
1 review
 

Chicken Parm Sub

made with your choice of sauce

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Pizza Sub

includes one topping, with your choice of sauce

8" $8.4912" $10.99
 

Stuffed Pepper Parm

made with your choice of sauce

8" +$9.9912" +$12.99
Stuffed Pepper Parm
 

Sandwiches

Served with fresh cut fries or deli style potato chips and a pickle.

Deluxe Grilled Cheese

$7.99

Melted yellow American, cheddar, provolone and Swiss-American between two pieces of Texas toast.

 

Chicken Salad

$8.99

Made fresh daily, served on Texas toast.

 

Bologna and Onion

$7.99

Thick-cut bologna with melted American cheese, served with side of mustard.

Bologna and Onion
 

Club Sandwich

$8.99

Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and mayonnaise between three pieces of Texas toast.

 

Seafood Dinners

Served on Fridays only.

Fish Fry

$13.99

Large piece of beer-battered cod served with fresh-cut fries, homemade coleslaw, tartar sauce, lemon wedge, and a piece of garlic toast.

Fish Fry
1 review
22 pops1 review
 

Shrimp Basket

$11.99

Ten (10) butterfly shrimp served with fresh-cut fries, homemade coleslaw, cocktail sauce, and a lemon wedge.

 

Pizza

Now offering our original semi-sweet sauce, or garlic marinara sauce. Semi-sweet will be served unless requested otherwise.
Add a garlic crust to any pizza!

Toppings:
Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Tomatoes, Ham, Spinach, Meatballs, Fresh Garlic and Cherry Peppers

Slice

$2.49
Toppings +$0.90
11 pop
 

Small

$13.99
Toppings +$1
Small
2 reviews
33 pops2 reviews
 

1/2 Tray

$21.99
Toppings +$3
1/2 Tray
4 reviews
4 reviews
 

Personal

$7.99
Toppings +$1
1 review
 

Large

$16.99
Toppings +$2.50
Large
3 reviews
4116 pops3 reviews
 

Tray

$27.99
Toppings +$4
Tray
 

Specialty Pizza

White Tomato and Onion

with our homemade white sauce

Small $17.99Large $20.991/2 Tray $25.99Tray $31.99
 

Pizza of the Month

pizza will change monthly. can be found on pizza specials menu tab

*THIS MONTH: FAT MAC*

Small +$17.99Large +$21.991/2 Tray +$27.49Tray +$33.99
Pizza of the Month
 

Poor Man's Lasagna

chopped meatballs, fresh ricotta and mozzarella on our garlic marinara sauce

Small $17.99Large $22.991/2 Tray $28.49Tray $34.99
Poor Man's Lasagna
1 review
1 review
 

Philly

(Steak or Chicken) With green peppers, mushrooms, and onions, plus a three-cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.

Small $17.99Large $23.991/2 Tray $29.49Tray $35.99
Philly
2 reviews
2 reviews
 

Stuffed Hungarian Pepper

with homemade stuffed hungarian peppers and a garlic butter sauce.

Small $18.99Large $23.991/2 Tray $29.49Tray $35.99
Stuffed Hungarian Pepper
1 review
1 review
 

Split

Get two different pizzas in one! Price will be determined by the higher priced pizza choice.
The Works is not available for split.

Large +$1.501/2 Tray +$2.25Tray +$3
Split
 

White Veggie

choice of up to four (4) toppings with our homemade white sauce

Small $17.99Large $20.991/2 Tray $25.99Tray $31.99
 

Chicken Finger

choice of fingers, with bleu cheese sauce.

Small $17.99Large $22.991/2 Tray $28.49Tray $32.99
Chicken Finger
1 review
22 pops1 review
 

Honey Sriracha

choice of pepperoni or sausage on our garlic marinara sauce with a honey sriracha drizzle and fried basil finish

Small $17.99Large $22.991/2 Tray $28.49Tray $34.99
Honey Sriracha
1 review
1 review
 

Meat Lovers

with pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon

Small $17.99Large $23.991/2 Tray $29.49Tray $35.99
Meat Lovers
 

The Works

with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, black olives, and green olives.
*NO SUBSTITUTIONS*

Small $19.99Large $25.991/2 Tray $31.49Tray $39.99
The Works
 

Calzones

(served with sides of pizza sauce unless specified otherwise)

Cheese Calzone

$8.99

With ricotta and mozzarella

 

Chicken Finger Calzone

$12.99

Choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese

11 pop1 review
 

Cheese and One-Item Calzone

$10.49

See pizza section for toppings

Cheese and One-Item Calzone
11 pop
 

Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Calzone

$12.99

With our homemade stuffed peppers

Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Calzone
1 review
11 pop1 review
 

Wings, Fingers & Boneless Wings

Sauce Options:
Plain, Hot, Medium, Mild and BBQ

Specialty Options: ($1.00 upcharge)
Cajun, Garlic Parm, Buffalo Garlic, Cajun BBQ, Horseradish Mustard, Mum's Sauce, Inferno*, Honey BBQ, Honey Hot, Honey Garlic, Honey Sriracha, Maple Bacon BBQ, Jamaican Jerk
(*wings cannot be returned for being too hot)

Try our wings and fingers on the chargrill! $1.00 upcharge ($2.00 for bucket of wings)

Extra Bleu Cheese $1.00 Extra Veggies $1.00

Chicken Wings

served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery

Single (10) +$11.99Double (20) +$20.99Triple (30) +$27.99Bucket (50) +$40.99
Chicken Wings
 

Boneless Wings

served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery

Single (12) +$10.99Double (24) +$19.99Triple (36) +$26.99Bucket (60) +$39.99
Boneless Wings
 

Chicken Fingers

served with fresh cut french fries, homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery

Single (6) +$10.99Double (12) +$19.99
Chicken Fingers
 

Everyday Combos & Specials

Slices (2) and Drink

$7.49

choice of cheese or cheese and pepperoni
with your choice of Pepsi products

11 pop
 

8" Sub, Side, and Drink

$3

add a side and drink to your 8" sub. with your choice of Pepsi products
fresh cut fries, deli chips or a salad +$3.00
homemade mac-n-cheese or onion rings +$4.00

Mac and Cheese +$1Onion Rings +$1
2 reviews
 

Large Pizza with one (1) Topping, 20 Wings

$37.99
4 reviews
 

Tray Pizza with one (1) Topping, 50 Wings

$67.99
 

Specialty Slice and Drink

$8.49

available weekdays, menu varies (located on Pizza Specials menu)
with your choice of Pepsi products

11 pop
 

Small Pizza with one (1) Topping, 10 Wings

$25.99
 

1/2 Tray Pizza (1) Topping, 30 Wings

$49.99
5 reviews
 

Desserts

Apple Pie Logs

$5.99

(5) served with caramel sauce

Apple Pie Logs
 

Cinnamon Sticks

$6.99

topped with vanilla icing

Cinnamon Sticks
 
Made with by Popmenu
Fatman's Pizza
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window