Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Fatman's Pizza. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
The food. Beautiful. The taste. Beautiful. The people. Beautiful. In the words of the terminator. "I'll be back"
My go to sauce choice on extra crispy wings. Just enough heat to satisfy while still enjoying all the flavor. 11/10. Would Order again.
Good pizza and excellent wings. Some of the best in Buffalo!
This sub was loaded with chicken fingers and flavor! Perfectly toasted roll, nicely sauced chicken fingers. Oil was tasty but not overwhelming.
The stuffed pepper pizza is the beat aroumd town never had anything like it.
OMG! So good! I have been disappointed by similar subs from other places but this one was fantastic! Steak and toppings were grilled to perfection and just the right amount of mayo.
Very tasty n yummy
This is Cajun bbq, but we have ordered Hot Cajun BBQ! And on the grill! Try it, they are fabulous! And Fatmans is the only place that we'll get 'these' from!
Fatman's Pizza is by far the best! We have tried some places in North Tonawanda but they don't even come close! There is just no comparison! The food is always amazingly delicious and the people there are always efficient,polite and friendly. Our favorite is the pizza and wings! The crust and sauce is perfect and the wings are always crispy and flavorful! No matter what you choose, you won't be disappointed! Give them a try!
Perfection! High quality meat, toasted roll and veggies just as ordered. Was even accommodating and added banana peppers for me. Best Steak Sub in WNY!
If you want some cheesy goodness this is the way to go!
Well, I have not only had their pizza and wings, I have had their chicken fingers, subs, fish fries to die for and they make their own Bleu cheese! Never had a bad meal, staff is nice, helpful and polite. I have popped in to get slices and even when I had to wait, it was never that long and always worth it! You will not be disappointed!
Four outta Five Stars I had to give two stars just for the croutons! They are without exception THE BEST CROUTONS I HAVE EVER HAD! Can I make an order for just croutons, is that a thing? The telephone customer service and the delivery services were also exceptional, for another two stars. On the flip side and about the fifth star, I must say that the sweet pizza sauce wasn't for me. I'm sorry to say that I couldn't eat it. I'm sure may folks like it, so I chose not to complain. Overall, I think they're great in more ways. So I definitely recommend Fatman's for those who like sweet pizza sauce.
Excellent pizza!! One of the best I've had in years! We've been meaning to try Fat Man's and were so pleasantly surprised with the great pizza, wings and stuffed peppers. Highly recommend them!
Wonderful sweet sauce and generous portion of cheese! Very satisfying!!
Loved it! Cooked to perfection!
I love the sweeter sauce, 10/10 cheese & pep
Thicc sticky sweet and smoky sauce was the perfect option for my chargrilled wings last night! Cooked perfectly and loaded with bbq sauce.
The mini is a great size for lunch. Make into a club, the bacon is incredible. Really can't go wrong on this menu!
Fresh cut fries are already a top tier fry choice, but these are cooked perfectly. Crispy and light. I'm a French fry snob and these are legit.
Awesome! also had a ham sub! Perfect!
Great pizza and wings!! Got the party tray with a bucket of wings and really enjoyed! Always friendly service and always accommodating! One of our kids likes his wings plain and other places won't let us order only 10 plain? Fatman's does not mind custom orders and aims to please! Highly recommended!!
We had the Hot Cajun chicken wings again, over the grill. They are fabulous! We also had med wings, the best around! They don't me x up your orders, forget something, they always have plenty of sauce on them and are never overcooked! (Unlike places closer to where we live in Tonawanda by Delaware Ave!) Their Onion Rings are also the Best!
The semi sweet sauce they use is AMAZING! I was never a fan of sweet sauce because they end up too sweet but this is the perfect combination. Pair it with their garlic crust and it's phenomenal. Highly recommend.
This calzone was amazing! I've had many many items from Fatman's and I've never been disappointed, always happy with everything. The calzone was packed full of cheeses and banana peppers and sausage, it was delicious. We also had the garlic parmesan wings and they were delicious as well and nice and crispy!
Our go to order is a cheese and pepperoni pizza & order of fries. Love that the fries are fresh cut and always fresh. Their pizza is my favorite in the Buffalo area. The original sauce is semi sweet, cup and char pepperoni, yum!
I've had a lot of steak subs, but this one is absolutely my favorite! I'm pretty sure it's the fact that it has peppers, onions, AND mushrooms, and the way the cheese melts into everything makes it so good. I HIGHLY recommend!
This is one of the many menu items we LOVE! Great food, always friendly staff. You will love it! Best pizza around!
Always perfect! I love the thin crust also!
Pepperoni Banana Pepper and garlic crust is the way to go!
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos
Elish, Crump's Landing
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria